Spice vs. Converted Cannabinoids: Clearing the Confusion

by Kevin Kimmell on Sep 15 2025

Table of Contents

The Real Story Behind the Confusion

In hemp debates, opponents often point to “Spice” or “K2” as if these products are interchangeable with hemp-derived cannabinoids like Delta-8 THC. On the surface, the comparison sounds scary. In reality, it’s misleading. Spice is a fully synthetic chemical blend with unpredictable effects. Hemp-derived cannabinoids, by contrast, start with a natural crop and can be manufactured and regulated responsibly.

The confusion matters because it shapes policy. Mislabeling hemp cannabinoids as “synthetic drugs” leads to reactionary bans, which do nothing to improve consumer safety. The real solution is clear, science-based regulation.

What Is spice?

Spice, also known by the popular name brand “K2”, refers to a mix of synthetic chemicals sprayed on plant material. It was created to mimic THC’s effects but is not related to cannabis or hemp.

A few key facts about spice:

Completely artificial: Spice is not derived from cannabis, it has said to have originated in a lab that was aiming to produce new synthetic cannabinoids for medications, but some compounds were illegally sold to bad actors.
Shifting formulas: Manufacturers often tweak ingredients to dodge enforcement.
Unpredictable risks: Linked to seizures, kidney damage, psychosis, and even deaths.

Between 2010 and 2015, U.S. poison centers logged over 7,700 exposures to synthetic cannabinoids requiring emergency medical attention (CDC, 2016). The CDC has warned that these products can cause “severe, life-threatening health effects” (CDC Overview).

What Are Converted Cannabinoids?

Converted cannabinoids such as Delta-8 THC or HHC start with CBD extracted from federally legal hemp. Through a conversion process, CBD is transformed into cannabinoids that also occur naturally in the cannabis plant.

Key facts about Cannabinoids:

Rooted in U.S. agriculture: Hemp is the starting point, grown by American farmers.
Produced in labs that can be regulated: With proper standards, products can be tested for purity and potency.
Structurally similar to natural cannabinoids: Delta-8 THC binds to the same receptors as Delta-9 THC (Wiley, 2022).
Verifiable: Independent lab reports can confirm potency, contaminants, and safety.
Regulation is critical: testing, labeling, and age restrictions give consumers accurate information and can reduce harm.

Why the Confusion Matters

The debate often comes down to one word: “synthetic.” Because converted cannabinoids require chemical processing, opponents use the same label applied to Spice. But that comparison doesn’t hold up. Many safe, everyday products — vitamins, caffeine, flavor extracts — are produced through chemical conversions. That does not make them dangerous.

Conflating Spice with hemp cannabinoids creates unnecessary fear and pushes policymakers toward blanket bans. Instead, we should distinguish between unregulated chemical blends with no natural origin and hemp-derived cannabinoids that can be safely brought to market with the right rules.

The Case for Regulation

Instead of banning hemp cannabinoids outright, lawmakers can protect consumers and support responsible businesses through regulation. Effective safeguards include:

Testing and QR-coded lab results for potency and contaminants.
Clear labeling with serving sizes, dosage, and health warnings.
Age restrictions and retail training to ensure responsible sales.
Child-resistant packaging that prevents accidental use.
Licensing and accountability for manufacturers and retailers.

These steps protect consumers while allowing farmers and small businesses to participate in a transparent, tax-paying industry. Prohibition does the opposite: it drives products underground and makes them less safe.

Learning From History

We’ve seen this before. Alcohol prohibition created bootleggers and unsafe products. Cannabis prohibition fueled one of the largest illicit markets in the world. Today, bans on hemp cannabinoids risk repeating the same mistake.

The smart path is not prohibition, but regulation — ensuring that consumers know what they are buying, businesses compete on quality, and policymakers have oversight.

The Bottom Line

Spice and hemp-derived cannabinoids are not the same. Spice is an unpredictable chemical blend with no relation to cannabis. Hemp-derived cannabinoids like Delta-8 THC begin with a natural crop, can be tested and labeled, and already support an emerging American industry.

Policymakers should stop blurring the lines and start building frameworks that keep consumers safe, support farmers, and grow the economy. Regulation, not prohibition, is how we move forward.